Skip to content Skip to main navigation Skip to footer

Public Comments

2026 Regular Session HB4413 (Health and Human Resources)
Comment by: Lake Sidikman on February 4, 2026 10:44
My name is Lake Sidikman and I am a licensed social worker and the Harm Reduction Program Coordinator at the Women's Health Center of West Virginia. I'm writing today to speak to the importance of Syringe Service Programs (SSPs). According to the CDC, SSPs can reduce rates of HIV and Hepatitis C spread by up to 50%, which in a state with a large HIV outbreak is a crucial public health intervention. People who use SSPs are also up to 5 times more likely to enter treatment for Substance Use Disorder- these programs help providers make sustained, meaningful connection with clients who might need extra time to enter recovery. Licensed SSPs in West Virginia have a legal obligation to provide wraparound services and outside referrals, carefully track and report data, and help people dispose of used syringes safely and consistently. Banning SSPs will not make people stop injecting drugs, it will force people to reuse syringes until they are dull and breaking and share syringes with other people and drastically increase their risk for disease. Not allowing people to have a safe place to dispose of used sharps and receive clean ones only increases the amount of used syringes in the community. SSPs are a medical service provided by people with expert knowledge, and a ban would infringe on the freedom of these experts to provide evidence-based, compassionate health care to West Virginians.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Allison Workman on February 4, 2026 10:39
Someone who causes the death of another through careless, reckless, and selfish actions must be held accountable. It was a choice to get behind the wheel while impaired, and that choice resulted in a life lost. Loving parents, a husband, friends, family, and an entire community are left heartbroken. They now carry an empty space in their hearts that can never be replaced or filled because of someone else’s actions. The person who made the choice to get behind the wheel must face justice, just as Baylea’s entire family is suffering, along with so many other families. Justice needs to be served.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Mike Buxton on February 4, 2026 10:39
I believe this law needs to be updated so people will think twice about what they are doing when under the influence. A stiffer penalty needs to be put in place for taking a life under these circumstances.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Hope Koon on February 4, 2026 10:38
Yes!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Quintin Goffe on February 4, 2026 10:36
People need to be held accountable for their actions.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Anita Perdue on February 4, 2026 10:33
This bill is far overdue! Our family is in total support! 💙
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Kara Slater on February 4, 2026 10:20
Driving while impaired should have harsher penalties than what we currently have.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Heather Bailey on February 4, 2026 10:17
If you choose to drive impaired and you hurt someone else the punishment should be much more than it is currently.  The person you hurt or killed will never be the same and neither will their families.  Justice for Baylea
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Morgan Winter on February 4, 2026 10:17
.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Jessica Vazquez on February 4, 2026 10:09
There needs to be harsher consequences for driving while under the influence and passing this bill will be the start!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Anna Puskas on February 4, 2026 10:06
I absolutely think there should be very stiff punishment for drunk drivers.  We need to STOP letting them get away with hardly no punishment.   They chose to drink and get in their car and kill innocent people.  PASS HOUSE BILL 4712 NOW.  Why if this was your daughter, wife, mother, friend, how would you feel?
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Brianna Smith on February 4, 2026 09:47
This law is important for many reasons, but the biggest one begin that there should be consequences for horrible decisions. As lawmakers, it is your job to protect citizens. Whenever that fails, those responsible should be held accountable. That accountability shouldn’t be a slap on the wrist.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: John Workman on February 4, 2026 09:40
House Bill 4712 needs passed to put stricter laws and penalties on people charged for their misbehavior,  misconduct and choices.
2026 Regular Session HB4052 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Cindy Murphy on February 4, 2026 09:37
As a retired career firefighter, I understand the need for distance to keep both the public and the civil servants safe. I do not believe this is the bill's true intent. I think it is another attempt to restrict the Constitutionally protected right to peaceful protest and for the documentation of the activities of DHS/ICE/Border Patrol or other law enforcement.
2026 Regular Session HB4467 (Public Education)
Comment by: Angela Catrow on February 4, 2026 09:24
Good morning!  I am so thankful to see this Bill.  Our county says we care about children. However, a few years ago, our secretary was hospitalized due to pregnancy complications.  I had over 100 sick days to bank but the state regulations do not allow employees who are hospitalized due to pregnancy complications to use the sick bank.  This is disturbing & so frustrating.  Our county has no paternity leave.  We are so short staffed.  People who are sick or hospitalized for other things can use the sick bank.  If someone is hospitalized due to pregnancy complications, they should also be able to use the sick bank.  This is a small benefit to ask for but a huge blessing to pregnant employees.  Please pass this bill!
2026 Regular Session SB4 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Cindy Murphy on February 4, 2026 09:17
I was a career firefighter for almost 30 years. I can see the need to keep bystanders back for their own safety and for the operation of public servants, be they firefighters, EMS, or law enforcement. Sadly, I don't believe that is your intent with this bill. I think you are trying to aid and abet the unconstitutional actions of DHS/ICE/Border Patrol to allow them to violate the Constitutional rights of both citizens and non-citizens. I believe it has very little to do with fire or ems and those agencies are being thrown in as if you are truly trying to protect us. The language in this bill states-"Harass" means to willfully engage in a course of conduct directed at a first responder which intentionally causes substantial emotional distress in that first responder and serves no legitimate purpose." That serves no legitimate purpose is the clue. Who gets to decide a legitimate purpose? Peaceful protest and documentation of what is going on are protected by the Constitution. Restricting the general public's ability to hold law enforcement, including federal agencies, accountable is your aim. This is wrong.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Christine Holstein on February 4, 2026 09:16
Getting behind the wheel of a car impaired and killing someone is MURDER, why would the law sentence them to any thing other than life in prison! It is no longer accident when they chose to drive under the influence!
2026 Regular Session HB4062 (Educational Choice)
Comment by: Jennifer York on February 4, 2026 09:12
I am in favor of this bill. Please pass this as it will bring more revenue to the sate of West Virginia and make all children feel included and not outcasts because of schooling choice.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Lawrence Peterson on February 4, 2026 09:11
I want this bill passed. It is the right thing to do and needs done now. Not either life lost this way. Thank you for your attention to this matter.
2026 Regular Session HB4168 (Health and Human Resources)
Comment by: Cindy Murphy on February 4, 2026 09:08
I believe that, unless there is a proven detriment, such as a child having an allergy to a vaccine or a condition that will be exacerbated by its administration, they should be required to have them to enter school. We are a very unhealthy state, and these are diseases we can prevent. I do not approve of the changes you are proposing to childhood vaccine administration related to enrollment.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Jeremiah Steele on February 4, 2026 09:05
I feel as if this bill should be passed because it feels like the punishment for the crime as of now is far to little taking a persons life is a huge thing and I feel it’s just a slap on the wrist right now
2026 Regular Session HB4103 (Education)
Comment by: Cindy Murphy on February 4, 2026 09:04
Instead of dealing with the major economic issues that WV has, or trying to ensure that WVians have clean water, you are once again trying to force WVians to submit to your religious beliefs. I am a Christian, and I believe that every individual has a right to practice that religion, regardless of what it is. Your insistence on violating the First Amendment of the US Constitution is disturbing and unbelievable. Let me remind you what the actual US Constitution says. This has been fought in the courts, and yet you persist. Our founding fathers put this in for a reason. Respect it. "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."
2026 Regular Session HB4100 (Education)
Comment by: Cindy Murphy on February 4, 2026 08:59
The new language in this bill should be removed and not rewritten in a different way to get this through the legislature. The baby Olivia video is nothing more than a prolife attempt to remove choice by intimidation. Young girls and women should have a choice, and this propaganda is meant to harass those making difficult decisions. Think of the poor girl who has been raped by her own father, brother, uncle, grandfather, or other man. You are shaming them into letting you make the decisions for them. It's ignorant and unkind. Again, WV has bigger problems, and instead of dealing with them, you are once again inserting your personal religious and political beliefs into the personal lives of females. Try actually regulating the horrible actions of men instead.
2026 Regular Session HB4073 (Health and Human Resources)
Comment by: Cindy Murphy on February 4, 2026 08:48
WV ranks  46th in overall health according to the United Health Foundation. We rank 47th in our overall health system performance,  50th for adult obesity, diabetes, and COPD, 49th in premature mortality rate, and we have the 2nd highest mortality rate in the country. These statistics show that WV doesn't need one more thing to make us less healthy, and yet you are proposing that we not mandate vaccines that have been proven for decades to save lives and prevent diseases. This bill makes no sense. Listen to the scientists, not the individuals with a political agenda.
2026 Regular Session HB4034 (Education)
Comment by: Cindy Murphy on February 4, 2026 08:38
First, let me say that I am a practicing Christian and believe in religious freedom, regardless of the religion. By ordering this in our public schools, you are violating the Constitution. This has been fought in the courts before. I truly believe you have many more important issues facing WV than trying to force everyone to follow the Christian religion. Let me remind you of what our ACTUAL US CONSTITUTION says in the very FIRST AMENDMENT: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances. Our forefathers did not want the government establishing religion, and you shouldn't either.  
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Brian Guthrie on February 4, 2026 08:38
Baylea was a beautiful young lady who had her whole life in front of her. She was so kind and full of life. Baylea truly had a heart of gold!  For her life to be tragically taken by someone so reckless with zero regard for life is incomprehensible. Not only did this human kill Baylea, but they killed so much inside everyone who knew her, that it cannot be measured. This crime must have eye opening consequences. If there is a silver lining to this horrific disregard of a beautiful life, it must come from the State of West Virginia by passing Baylea’s law. You have a golden opportunity. Send a message!
2026 Regular Session HB4025 (Government Organization)
Comment by: Cindy Murphy on February 4, 2026 08:32
It is ridiculous to once again try to take protections away from civil servants, including those you have yet to hire. This is a bad bill.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Brittany Epling on February 4, 2026 08:29
I was one of Baylea’s teachers. She among many others deserves justice.
2026 Regular Session HB4669 (Health and Human Resources)
Comment by: Carly Scala on February 4, 2026 08:15
If passed, this bill would eliminate one of the most effective, evidence-based public health measures for preventing tooth decay—particularly impacting children, rural residents, seniors, low-income families, and individuals with limited access to dental care. Community water fluoridation at the optimal level of 0.7 parts per million (ppm) is recommended by the U.S. Public Health Service and supported by decades of scientific research. Fluoridated water has been shown to reduce tooth decay by approximately 25% in both children and adults, even in communities where fluoride toothpaste is widely used. This issue is especially critical for West Virginia, where oral health disparities remain significant and many residents face barriers to routine dental care. Removing fluoride from community water systems would increase preventable dental disease, raise treatment costs, and place additional strain on families, schools, and the health care system. Water fluoridation protects WVians who do not have access to care - meaning those who lack transportation, have low health literacy, or are otherwise unable to receive education and care from dental providers. Water fluoridation costs much less for communities than the negative dental outcomes to come from removing accessible means of prevention. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/fluoride-in-drinking-water-is-safe-heres-the-evidence/
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Madilyn Lucas on February 4, 2026 07:50
I belive making the sentencing longer will make people regret even more on the decision they’ve decided to make.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Marilyn Kay Ferrell on February 4, 2026 07:12
Please put this bill thru
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: stephanie Donohue on February 4, 2026 07:01
Justice for Bailey please pass Bailey’s law.
2026 Regular Session HB4413 (Health and Human Resources)
Comment by: Rebekah Aranda on February 4, 2026 06:54
Needle exchange programs are a much debated but nevertheless well documented force for good in the world of infectious disease control/prevention (https://gmr.scholasticahq.com/article/83277-a-case-for-needle-exchange-programs-not-letting-perfection-be-the-enemy-of-the-good,) and yet this bill would eliminate these programs due to an ill-conceived notion that our communities our better off without these lifesaving programs in our public health settings. Participation in needle exchange prevents the spread of blood borne disease, while simultaneously acting as an entryway to allow people experiencing substance use disorder access into recovery and other harm reduction programming. If you do not care for the health of the most downtrodden in our community, then you should at least understand and consider that ending these programs will cost the state more to care for new HIV and Hepatitis C patients who will contract these diseases without clean needle access and rely on the state for lifelong follow up medical care.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Olivia Stear on February 4, 2026 06:52
Baylea was robbed of so many life moments, as should people who drink & drive that result in death. Taking a life so recklessly should mean that the person who caused it should face higher sentencing & punishment
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Cody pridemore on February 4, 2026 06:40
I agree with this!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Rita Buzzard on February 4, 2026 06:01
Yes I agree that this Bill should be passed.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Pamela maynor on February 4, 2026 05:52
I totally agree with this law justice for baylee
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Crystal on February 4, 2026 05:52
This bill needs passed too many people are dying because of drunk drivers
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Morgan on February 4, 2026 05:36
This law needs to go into effect. No one, under any circumstances, should be driving impaired in any way. Baylea was a light to the community and anyone around her. The loss of her is felt deeply and will be felt every day.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Karen Sue Runion on February 4, 2026 03:48
It's a tragic loss of innocent lives people don't think before they get behind the wheel that they are gonna take innocent lives and forever change families forever they usually get slaps on the wrist . They take a life get a little time and they are done but that families and loved ones has to carry the pain forever also  a lot of the times they become repeat offenders so with a little bit of hope this bill would help prevent it from happening to some one else's loved one .
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Jami Cobb on February 4, 2026 03:15
  1.  The punishment should be life in prison for dui causing death but this is a start! Hopefully they pass it soon and my sister in laws brother’s murderer will get the max 30 instead of 15. Driving under the influence of anything is 100% a choice just like pulling the trigger and 💀someone.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Sherry Lester on February 4, 2026 03:01
Too many people are being killed by drunk drivers! There needs to be more accountability for these people that choose to drink and then get behind the wheel of a vehicle knowing that they could take someone else’s life!!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Savannah on February 4, 2026 01:33
As someone who has suffered loss at the hand of an impaired driver, whether it be alcohol or drug, I support this! As someone who used to be on the volunteer fire department, I’ve ran many emergency calls due to someone who is not in the right state of mind while under the influence of alcohol or drugs. While many of those calls did not have a fatality, there were quite a few that have been engraved into my memory that were a fatality. There’s nothing like explaining to a that their loved one has been taken away at the hands of someone who is careless & irresponsible, which they chose to drive without thinking about others who could be involved potentially. while most of those calls involved adults that were injured or ended up being a fatality due to the impaired driver, a few of those ended up being a fatality or a critical injury of a child. there’s no pain like feeling the pain of a parent or a grandparent or a sibling when you have to explain that they’re loved one has been taken from them or has been critically injured. please pass this bill, so that maybe the next impaired driver will think twice about the consequences of their actions if they take someone’s loved ones away at the hands of their own irresponsible acts.  please pass this bill to let everyone know that is driving impaired that this is going to be taken seriously, so that someone else does not have to be a statistic on a chart at the hands of an impaired driver. the family of this girl does deserve justice, as well as families before her, and I feel that if this bill gets passed, that maybe the statistics will change for the better instead of continue to change for the worse. maybe there will be less impaired drivers on the highways risking the lives of other innocent bystanders. or better yet maybe this will alert them enough to know they need to have someone as a designated driver if  they are impaired! once you ran a fatality call that is one thing you could never get out of your mind! the scene, the smell, the screams, the cries for help, most importantly, the loss of someone.
2026 Regular Session HB5107 (Health and Human Resources)
Comment by: Cristy Anderson on February 4, 2026 01:10
Regarding substance abuse treatment, can you define in greater detail what you mean by “successfully fulfilling the treatment obligation in the program” for reunification? Does this mean completing a program? Are non-compliance issues a setback? From what I have seen, there are so many chances given WHILE kids are being reunified.  A certain threshold of sobriety or progression through rehab services should be required before ordering any type of reunification. This is as much from a physical safety standpoint as it is an emotional and psychological one. When non-compliance issues are not treated seriously, safety becomes a concern. When non-compliance issues are treated seriously, kids have a planned visit with their parent only to learn that visitation will not be happening. They aren’t too old before they start to piece together that Mom and Dad isn’t testing properly or going through the steps. The participant just needs to be far enough in a program or completely done before attempting to reunify. And please outright ban the term “parental alienation“ or “alienating behaviors“ or anything related to the concept from ever being able to be introduced into the equation. This happens with regularity and the non-abusing parent all of a sudden becomes the target when the abusive parent raises an allegation of alienation. Full custody flips have actually happened in the state, resulting in the non-abusing parent losing custody to fix the broken relationship between the child and abusive parent.    
2026 Regular Session HB4413 (Health and Human Resources)
Comment by: Tasha Withrow on February 4, 2026 00:05

I oppose this bill, which would repeal West Virginia’s syringe services framework and declare syringe services programs unlawful.

This legislation would cause real and foreseeable harm to public health. Syringe services programs are one of the most extensively studied and effective tools we have to prevent the spread of HIV and hepatitis, reduce overdose deaths, and connect people to treatment. Eliminating them does not stop drug use—it increases disease, medical costs, and death.

West Virginia has already experienced outbreaks of HIV and hepatitis C tied directly to injection drug use. Syringe services programs exist precisely to prevent those outcomes. Treating HIV or hepatitis C costs hundreds of thousands of dollars per person over a lifetime. Prevention costs far less. This bill shifts the burden from prevention to emergency rooms, hospitals, and taxpayers.

While the bill claims to preserve “harm reduction services,” it removes the very service that makes harm reduction effective for people who inject drugs: access to sterile syringes. Without that access, many people will not engage at all. Education, referrals, and screenings do not work if the door is closed to the people most at risk.

Syringe services programs are also a critical pathway to overdose prevention. They are a primary source of naloxone distribution, overdose education, and early engagement with treatment. When these programs are shut down, overdose deaths increase—not because drug use increases, but because people are pushed into more dangerous and isolated conditions.

This bill replaces regulation with prohibition and punishment. That approach will not eliminate syringe use. It will drive it underground, reduce safe disposal, increase needle litter, and remove state oversight entirely. Regulated programs allow accountability. Bans do not.

The so-called transition period offered in this bill is inadequate and contradictory. Providers are expected to help patients transition away from services while being prohibited from providing the very service that keeps those patients engaged. That is not continuity of care—it is abrupt disengagement.

Finally, this bill ignores overwhelming medical and public health consensus. Syringe services programs are supported because they work. Public policy should be guided by evidence and outcomes, not fear or ideology.

This legislation will increase disease transmission, increase overdose deaths, increase health care costs, and weaken public health oversight. West Virginia should strengthen and improve syringe services programs—not outlaw them.

For these reasons, I urge you to reject this bill.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Cassie Hudson on February 3, 2026 23:59
  1. My family lost a very special person when we lost Baylea, I can’t tell you in words what her loss has meant to us she was there for us when we needed her the most. I feel anyone you chooses to drink and drive should be punished to maximum punishment and it shouldn’t be what it is now. They need a reason not to do it make it stricter make them scared to get behind a wheel. Please because the laws we have now is a slap on the wrist make them realize they made a choice and see what they are taking away. She was a daughter, wife, sister,aunt,  and a future mother.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Jonathan on February 3, 2026 23:54
-j
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Hannah Adkins on February 3, 2026 23:51
Please pass this bill on behalf of the young woman for whom it represents.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Trinity king on February 3, 2026 23:43
Hope this girl gets arrested and serves her justice. It is very wrong for her to do that, and she deserves this so justice for baliee
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Alesha on February 3, 2026 23:43
Justice for Baylea!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Brooks Adkins on February 3, 2026 23:40
Should be passed
2026 Regular Session HB4794 (Education)
Comment by: Lori Mathieu on February 3, 2026 23:38
It appears that the majority of the bills you are trying to get passed are stacking the deck against public education, I don’t understand how you are thinking or what your motives are. Our students should understand and know the Constitution and more importantly their Constitutional rights, but if you are, as a legislative body are not fighting right now to support all of the Constitutional rights afforded to every single person in this country, then it is very hypocritical for you to pass a bill that would require only public school  students to take a test to be able to graduate. Further more, this same body of legislators is actively supporting a bill, SB216, that would remove standards like this from charter and private schools’ requirements. Kill this bill! Especially since you are not practicing what you are wanting them to learn!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Shelby Mitchem on February 3, 2026 23:31
Please pass Baylea's Bill! No one should have to grieve their loved one for someone's mistake
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Kim Adkins on February 3, 2026 23:18
Pass Baylea’s  law!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Paul Foster on February 3, 2026 22:44
I believe people need to be held accountable for their actions longer a couple years. Paul Foster
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Kristin Ayers on February 3, 2026 22:44
I believe this bill should be passed to give families justice after losing a loved one to drunk driving. Our state faces many challenges and they begin with our youth drinking which typically leads to drug use into adult life. The person who took Baylea’s life had used both that night. Two families were ruined and one will never be able to share another moment with their daughter because of the actions of someone else. Our state should begin to take these matters more serious to help families feel some sort of justice.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Robin Muncy on February 3, 2026 22:38
Men and Women of WV legislation, As an Elected Representative of WV legislature I feel it is your duty in making sure not only our state is governed by the proper laws but also our people should be protected by them. In saying that I am referring to the law that is in place at the current time on impaired driving causing death. With WV having one of the highest fatality rate in the nation and in 2024 with 78 fatalities involving impaired driving I feel the law for this crime is not only strong enough but needs to be enforced to the fullest extent possible. When someone has no regard not only for their life but everyone they pass along the road while impaired should get no sympathy. They make that choice and all choices have consequences. You should ask yourself what kind of justice do you feel would be expected if that was one of your loved ones that was taken away from someone that chose to get impaired and drive. As of date this law only holds 3 to 15 years in prison with I’m sure not many are convicted to the fullest extent possible. When the victims family is left behind to live a life sentence of grief. We need stronger laws!! I hope each and everyone of you can see where HB 1234 “Baylea’s Law” will not only be the start in the right direction to protecting the innocent people of WV but hopefully be the reason someone does not have to say goodbye to a loved one. Please do what’s right for the people of WV and vote yes to HB 1234 “Baylea’s Law”.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Amber lilly on February 3, 2026 22:36
I agree we should have tougher laws against DUI and death caused by Dui
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Cathy S Acord on February 3, 2026 22:34
Please consider the 6 year minimum-30 year maximum punishment for this particular crime. Please do the right thing! Cathy S Acord
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Cathy Estes-Zornes on February 3, 2026 22:26
I believe a review of the current D.U.I. Law is necessary. The punishment should match the level of the crime. Taking a life when you could have prevented it should have harsher consequences.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Paul Foster on February 3, 2026 22:25
There needs The Stiffler penalty on DUI with death it’s not fair to the loved ones that loses someone to a tragic accident by someone that chooses to drink and drive and take another person‘s life. 3 to 15 years is just small enough for something like this. It needs to be more. It’s basically a slap on a wrist for 3 to 15 is all it is I think the families and the victims deserves more. How would anyone in Legislation feel if it was a family member yours while your kids that this might happen to you would feel the same.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Mackenzie Smith on February 3, 2026 22:17
Baylea was an amazing human who had so much more time on this earth. We as a state need to crack down on drunk/buzzed driving. No amount of time will make up for the loss of this sweet girl but the least she deserves is full justice!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Courtney Epling on February 3, 2026 22:15
Pass Bayleas Law!
2026 Regular Session HB4834 (Education)
Comment by: Hannah Critchley on February 3, 2026 22:15
I have a middle school daughter and son.   She has begged to wrestle, but I have not been comfortable with her wrestling boys.  She stands to the side as her brother excels.   The sport of wrestling is exploding for girls.  There are so many wrestling scholarships available for them.  Our girls are at a disadvantage in the state.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Nick Mullins on February 3, 2026 22:14
harsher punishments for these such acts could prevent future lives lost in these choice events. The choice to break the law while DUI should be held more than what it does now period. Due to how many repeat offenders get caught more and more, and some that never get caught but still continue to do it so often .
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Cathy on February 3, 2026 22:12
People who drink alcohol and/or use drugs and operate a vehicle should suffer harsher consequences, especially when they take an innocent person’s life.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Donna Roberts on February 3, 2026 22:07
Please pass this bill. Baylee deserves to still be alive,
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Denise R. Deskins on February 3, 2026 22:06
  1. People need to be held accountable
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Teresa Scarbro on February 3, 2026 22:01
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Layne Daniel on February 3, 2026 22:00
One of the best bills that I have seen introduced in the last 7 years. Anyone who makes the choice to drive under the influence and takes someone’s life it is no different than an accidental homicide.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Teresa Scarbro on February 3, 2026 22:00
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Jennifer Milam on February 3, 2026 21:52
This law should be passed. What if it was your child? What if you were in these sweet parent's shoes? The law that is in place is not enough and is the reason people continues to do it. A slap on the wrist is not ok for this kind of behavior. She took an innocent life, her life needs to be behind bars for murder not on probation doing what ever she wants at home.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Chris Duncan on February 3, 2026 21:46
This law needs changed to have stricter consequences for the actions of drivers who drive impaired. Too many families have lost ones to impaired drivers and the law currently doesn’t punish people who choose to drive impaired.  With stricter laws maybe people will think before they get behind the wheel while they are impaired and possibly take an innocent life.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Allison Jamison on February 3, 2026 21:45
Good luck!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Alyssa Higginbotham on February 3, 2026 21:43
I fully support this bill. My brother was just killed by a drunk driver on September 18, 2025. He left behind a wife and 3 small children. The man who was driving drunk at 6 AM only spent a couple of nights in jail and was released on a lesser bond. Original bond was 250,000 cash only. He was released on a 50,000 surety bond. We couldn’t even have an open casket for my brother. The fines should be massive and jail sentence should be longer. I honestly believe it should be a murder charge and life in prison because driving under the influence is a choice just like murder with any other weapon.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Aleta Scarbro on February 3, 2026 21:43
Please pass Bill 4712. I am in support of this Bill
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Nancy Armentrout on February 3, 2026 21:42
Please pass this bill it will save lives and make people think more before they choose to drive impaired.
2026 Regular Session HB4600 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Russell Williams on February 3, 2026 21:34
I am writing to you this evening as a representative of the ACLU of West Virginia to express our opposition to HB4600.   With the U.S. Post Office experiencing historic delays and struggling to keep up with mail volume, this bill would add to uncertainty for many West Virginia voters about whether their votes will be counted. West Virginians working and serving overseas could have their ballots thrown out, removing their voices from the very democracy some swore an oath to defend.   Absentee voter fraud is extremely rare and has never altered the outcome of an election. Even according to the far-right Heritage Foundation, there have only been five credible cases regarding fraudulent use of absentee ballots in West Virginia since 2012.   HB4600 is a solution in search of a problem that simply does not exist in West Virginia, and therefore should be soundly rejected.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Amanda loftis on February 3, 2026 21:33
I think anyone behind the wheel drunk should be max penalty! Think if this was your family they killed! All because they chose to be impaired behind the wheel!!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Marsha Doss on February 3, 2026 21:33
Please pass Bayleas Law
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Breanna Mills on February 3, 2026 21:30
It is important this bill is passed so no one’s life is affected from a wreckless drunk driver. An innocent life’s family will never be the same. The prison time should be doubled and double fine for their crime. The punishment should be upheld properly for the offender.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Tyan Lester on February 3, 2026 21:29
Stiffer penalties for DUI is a must due reoccurring offense.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Amber Castle on February 3, 2026 21:25
  1. Please pass Baylea’s Law in remembrance of a beautiful soul gone too soon  due to an impaired driver and for the safety and protection of WV citizens.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Adreona Brewer on February 3, 2026 21:25
Drunk drivers should face real consequences, not receive a slap in the wrist.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Chelsea Canterbury on February 3, 2026 21:25
Yes I agree. This should not be tolerated driving under the influence and taking a life.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Kaylee W on February 3, 2026 21:24
Baylea was a beautiful soul gone way too soon. I believe 100% this should become a law. I had a family member taken way too soon by the same situation. These people should get the maximum sentences. Love and prayers for the family!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Sydney Weikle on February 3, 2026 21:06
I strongly support the passage of this bill to increase penalties for DUI offenses that result in death. Driving under the influence is a conscious decision, and when that decision ends a life, the consequences must reflect the gravity of the harm caused. Families who lose loved ones to impaired drivers suffer irreversible loss, yet current sentencing often fails to deliver true accountability or deterrence. Strengthening penalties for DUI resulting in death sends a clear message: reckless and impaired driving will not be tolerated, and human life must be protected. This bill prioritizes public safety, justice for victims, and responsibility for dangerous choices. I urge you to pass this legislation and stand with families, communities, and law-abiding citizens who deserve safer roads. Thank you for taking action on this critical issue.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Jayson sperry on February 3, 2026 20:52
I feel this would definitely make people think about not drinking and driving because you never know if the other car is someone’s daughter, son, mom, dad anyone of someone’s family.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Tabitha on February 3, 2026 20:48
There definitely needs harsher punishments for those driving under the influence.  In this case Bailey died because of someone’s ignorance. 9-11-1990 my dad only 28 at that time, was driving with his coworker in passenger seat. He saw Larry Bird driving in his lane and swerved over into the ditch and he STILL hit them head on. Dad was comatose for days and now has seizures never to drive again. His coworker was injured as well ending up in a wheelchair.  All the driver got was broken leg and pretty sure my family said he had another accident months later.  He got NO punishment and ruined my dad’s ability to ever work again or live a normal life.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Megan Mitchem on February 3, 2026 20:42
I pray the family of Baylea gets the justice they deserve. She was a beautiful soul💕
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Kimberlee McCormick on February 3, 2026 20:40
Please consider passing this law.
2026 Regular Session HB4794 (Education)
Comment by: Kira Northup on February 3, 2026 20:31
Questions: As a mother of a special education student (autism and learning disability in reading), I am wondering if students with IEPs are still required to pass this test, and if so, what accommodations are allowed? As a taxpayer, is this only for public education students, or those in private schools and homeschooling as well?  If only public education, why are these the only students who need to have a knowledge on our constitution?  If ALL students (including private and homeschool) are tested, how will this be monitored outside of the public school setting?   Comments: As a public educator, I am against this bill. If we are simply giving the test (possibly multiple times) just so they have an “acute knowledge” of the constitution, why not just make a lesson plan or video to be taught/shown to all students. If a student fails this test multiple times and has to retake it, think of the education they are missing out on by being tested again and again, instead of being in the classroom where instruction is being delivered.  
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Mandi Johnson on February 3, 2026 20:26
I support stronger penalties
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Angel Steplowski on February 3, 2026 20:21
The current punishment for DUI causing death is far too minimum. DUI causing death should be considered a very serious charge, considering many people in the state of West Virginia, specifically southern West Virginia, have lost their lives due to people driving impaired. Isaiah Brown and Baylea Bower are examples of two very young people that had their entire lives to live, but were cut short because of two people’s bad decisions to drive impaired. Increasing the fines and jail time, could possibly help prevent people from driving impaired.
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Lesley lafferty on February 3, 2026 20:13
Pass the law !!!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Anthony Mullins on February 3, 2026 20:04

I fully support this new law. It’s a good improvement on the existing DUI causing death. Honestly, wish it was more but I’ll take this. Thank you.

2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Emily Schoolcraft on February 3, 2026 19:56
I feel strongly about this!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Jennifer on February 3, 2026 19:55
Hello! I am asking for stronger laws and harsher penalties against drunk driving in honor of a beautiful young girl whose life was taken far too soon, Baylea. Baylea had dreams, plans, and a whole future ahead of her. She was loved deeply, and her presence brought light to those around her. In a single, preventable moment, her life was stolen by someone who chose to drive under the influence. That decision forever changed countless lives. Drunk driving is 100% preventable, yet it continues to take innocent lives every single day. Current laws are clearly not strong enough to stop these tragedies from happening again and again. We urge lawmakers to strengthen DUI laws by: Increasing penalties for impaired driving Enforcing stricter sentencing for repeat offenders Expanding education and prevention programs Implementing tougher license suspensions and monitoring No family should ever have to bury a spouse, a child, sibling, or any loved one period because of someone else’s reckless choice. Let her story be the reason meaningful change happens. Let her life matter. Let her legacy save others. We are begging…
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Kaylee on February 3, 2026 19:50
JUSTICE FOR BAYLEA!
2026 Regular Session HB4712 (Judiciary)
Comment by: Tara Hamm on February 3, 2026 19:41
When someone decides to get behind the wheel while intoxicated they are not only putting their life in dangers but others as well.